Alpha (α)

Alpha vs. Beta in Finance: What is the Difference?

Beta, in contrast to the concept of alpha, measures the risk/returns of the broader market, above which investors attempt to achieve returns.

In other words, beta is the minimum return for investors – or more specifically, the hurdle that “active” investors like hedge funds must exceed.

If not, investor capital would be better off being allocated to passive index investments (e.g. ETFs) that track the overall market performance.

Here, assuming the alpha is equal to zero, that would imply that the portfolio is tracking the broader market.

Active investment firms’ offerings should provide a benefit – either above-market returns or more stability (i.e. market hedge) – for their limited partners (LPs) to have an incentive to provide funding.

With that said, LPs of actively managed funds that prioritize high returns will gauge the investment acumen of a potential investment firm by tracking their historical alpha.

Stock Portfolio Alpha Calculation Example

For instance, if an investment strategy has generated an alpha of 2%, that means the portfolio outperformed the market by 2%.

Conversely, a negative alpha of 2% means the portfolio underperformed the market by 2%.

Considering the fee structure – which is particularly high in the hedge fund industry (i.e. the “2 and 20” fee arrangement) – active investors must reasonably outperform the market or have consistent returns independent of the market.

In the latter, certain investment strategies seek not to outperform the market but to have sustainable low-risk returns, regardless of whether it is a bull or bear market.

Alpha vs. Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH)

For investors, alpha can stem from market efficiencies, irrational investor sentiment (i.e. herd-based mentality coupled with behavioral overreaction), or unexpected structural events (e.g. changes in rules and regulations).

The pursuit of alpha, generally speaking, tends to require a contrarian bet against the consensus and capitalizing on trends that most could not anticipate (i.e. Black Swan Event).

The efficient market hypothesis (EMH) states that alpha, at least over the long run, cannot be reasonably and consistently produced since the market on average is “correct.”

Based on that premise, active investing strategies are obsolete across long time horizons.

However, generating alpha is easier said than done, as confirmed by the wave of hedge fund closures in recent years.