What is Premiums Paid Analysis?
A “purchase premium” in the context of mergers and acquisitions refers to the excess that an acquirer pays over the market trading value of the shares being acquired. “Premiums Paid Analysis” is the name of a common investment banking analysis that reviews comparable transactions and averages the premiums paid for those transactions. Looking at historical premiums when negotiating the acquisition of a public company is a key part of framing the purchase price range. Additionally, the selling company’s management team will retain an investment bank to analyze historical premiums paid on comparable transactions to demonstrate to their shareholders that they have done their duty of maximizing value to shareholders.
Purchase Premium in M&A: Historical Average Range (%)
The vast majority (83%) of global M&A deals in 2016 had premiums between 10-50%, according to Bloomberg. When Microsoft acquired LinkedIn on June 13, 2016, it paid $196 per share, representing a 49.5% premium over LinkedIn’s closing share price of $131.08 per share the day prior to the deal announcement.
Premiums tend to be higher in strategic deals (one company acquiring another company) as opposed to financial deals (a private equity firm acquiring a company). That’s because a strategic acquirer often gains cost savings (synergies) from the newly combined firm that increases how much it can afford to pay.
Unaffected Share Price and Date
A complication in calculating the premium paid in a transaction is that oftentimes, rumors of the deal reach the public before the announcement, leading to a run-up in the target share price. In order to accurately calculate a premium, the denominator (i.e. the pre-deal share price) needs to be “unaffected” by the acquisition.
We can determine whether a price was affected by the deal news by observing the trading volume in the days leading up to the announcement date. For example, observe how trading volume appeared normal the day prior to the Microsoft/LinkedIn announcement, followed by a major volume spike and price increase1 on the announcement date:
Deals for which rumors get out will show spikes in trading volume prior to the announcement date. One consequence of this is that when investment bankers calculate purchase premiums, they also calculate the following:
- Premium over the day prior to announcement
- Premium over 1 week prior to announcement
- Premium over 1 month prior to announcement
Premium Paid Analysis Example: Dell Management Buyout (MBO)
Below is an example of how premiums analysis is presented in practice: On February 4, 2013, Dell’s board gathered to make the final decision on whether to approve a Michael Dell-led management buyout (MBO), which is a (LBO) carried out by the existing management.
Michael Dell, along with private equity firm Silver Lake, was offering $13.65 per share in cash to each shareholder excluding Michael Dell (he would rollover his equity into the newly-privatized company). Dell’s investment banker, Evercore Partners, made the following presentation to the board, which shows the $13.65 per-share offer price compared to Dell’s prior pre-MBO share prices at various dates:
As you can see, the premium was determined to be 25.5%, based on an unaffected share price of $10.88 on 1/1//2013. As you can see, Evercore set the unaffected price at a date several weeks before the announcement because rumors of the deal had leaked out.
In contrast, when Microsoft acquired LinkedIn, the unaffected date was simply the day before the acquisition, as trading volume and share price activity suggested no rumors had gotten out.
Premiums Paid Analysis Presentation Material
Later on in the presentation, Evercore also presents a premiums paid analysis — a common analysis made by investment bankers when advising a public target. The premiums paid analysis reviews historical transactions comparable to the active deal and averages the premiums paid for those transactions. Presumably, the average of the premiums from those deals should be near where the active deal should end up.
The output in Dell’s case, as you can see below, are premiums for comparable transactions in the mid 20%s – exactly in line with the 25.5% premium being offered.
After Dell and Silver Lake completed the buyout, shareholders who voted against the sale successfully sued Dell, arguing that the premium offered was insufficient. This ruling was later overturned, but not before sending shockwaves throughout the M&A world.
How to Find Historical Prices for Delisted Stocks
The historical share prices for companies that have been acquired, and thus delisted, aren’t as widely available as current actively traded shares. For example, once LinkedIn delisted at the close of the sale, most free services like Yahoo Finance no longer provided its share price data.
Subscription-based financial data providers like CapitalIQ, Factset, Bloomberg and Thomson do keep historical prices for delisted companies, as do some lesser known free services such as historicalstockprice.com and investing.com.
1 Notice that LinkedIn’s share price jumped to $192.21, whereas the offer price was $196. Upon an acquisition announcement, target shares often creep towards the offer price, but usually don’t get there. Click here to learn why.